Start practising

Advantages and Disadvantages Society Task 2

Large supermarkets have replaced most small local shops in many towns.

A full IELTS Writing Task 2 answer to this question, with a paragraph plan, ideas you can use, and the vocabulary that fits this topic.

The question

You should spend about 40 minutes on this task.

Large supermarkets have replaced most small local shops in many towns.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of this?

Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.

Write at least 250 words.

How to read this question

The organising idea worth reaching for is that supermarkets did not simply outcompete small shops on price — they changed what a shop is for, absorbing the butcher, baker, greengrocer and pharmacy into one trip. That explains both the scale of the convenience gain and why the loss is felt as more than a commercial one, and it keeps the essay away from simple nostalgia.

Paragraph plan

Introduction — Paraphrase the trend, then signpost: substantial gains in price, range and time; losses in local employment structure, in access for the immobile, and in the social function of a high street.

Body 1 — Advantages — buying power lowers prices for people who need that most, and one trip replaces five.

Body 2 — Disadvantages — money leaves the area rather than circulating in it, out-of-town siting excludes those without cars, and the incidental social contact disappears.

Conclusion — The gains are real and unevenly matched by the losses, which fall on the least mobile.

Model essay

Band 8.5–9.0 model essay

307 words

In numerous towns across the world, sprawling supermarket chains have supplanted the majority of small, independently owned shops that once formed the backbone of local commerce. Although this trend can produce some merits, it can also lead to some issues.

On the one hand, this development carries two notable benefits. First, supermarkets typically offer significantly lower prices than small shops, since their considerable purchasing power allows them to negotiate favourable deals with suppliers and pass these savings on to customers. This particularly benefits low-income households, for whom grocery expenses constitute a substantial proportion of monthly spending, meaning even modest price reductions can meaningfully ease household budgets. Second, supermarkets provide unmatched convenience by consolidating a vast range of products, from fresh produce to household goods, under a single roof. Consequently, shoppers can complete their weekly errands in one visit rather than travelling between several specialised local shops, saving considerable time and effort, an advantage especially valued by working parents with limited free time.

On the other hand, this trend also entails two significant drawbacks. First, small local shops, unable to compete with supermarket pricing, are frequently forced out of business, resulting in job losses among local shop owners and their employees, many of whom struggle to find comparable alternative employment given their specialised, narrow skill sets. Second, the disappearance of local shops can erode the sense of community within a town. To clarify, small shopkeepers often know their customers personally and provide a social meeting point where neighbours exchange news, whereas supermarket transactions tend to be impersonal and transactional, weakening the informal social bonds that once characterised town centres.

To conclude, the expansion of supermarkets at the expense of small local shops offers lower prices and greater convenience for consumers, while simultaneously threatening local employment and eroding the community connections that small businesses traditionally fostered within town centres.

Created by a Band 8.5–9.0 IELTS Writing achiever — Premium. Sign up free to read the rest of this essay and unlock every model on the site.

Get free access →

This is an advantages and disadvantages question. The essay above shows you what a strong answer looks like when it is finished. What it cannot show you is how to get there from a blank page in forty minutes.

That is what our Writing Study Library is for: the structure we teach for this exact question type, the paragraph pattern that goes with it, and the sentence openers for each stage — so the essay is planned before you start writing rather than assembled as you go.

See the structure for this question type →

Ideas & vocabulary for this topic

Ideas you can use

  • Introduction: Paraphrase how supermarket chains have replaced most small local shops and preview that the essay will present both merits and issues without taking sides.
  • Body 1: Give two advantages: supermarkets' bulk purchasing power brings lower prices that especially help low-income households, and consolidating everything under one roof saves shoppers, particularly busy parents, time and effort.
  • Body 2: Give two disadvantages: small shop owners and staff lose their livelihoods when they cannot compete on price, and the loss of personal shopkeeper relationships weakens the informal social bonds that held town centres together.
  • Conclusion: Summarise neutrally that supermarkets bring lower prices and convenience while threatening local jobs and eroding community ties, without stating a personal preference.
Word or phraseMeaningUsed in a sentence
supplantto take the place of, especially by force or more effective meanssprawling supermarket chains have supplanted the majority of small, independently owned shops
purchasing powerthe ability of a buyer to negotiate favourable prices, often through bulk buyingtheir considerable purchasing power allows them to negotiate favourable deals with suppliers
consolidatingcombining multiple things into a single, more effective wholesupermarkets provide unmatched convenience by consolidating a vast range of products...under a single roof
errandsshort trips or tasks done to obtain somethingshoppers can complete their weekly errands in one visit
forced out of businesscompelled to close because unable to competesmall local shops...are frequently forced out of business
comparablesimilar in nature and able to be comparedmany of whom struggle to find comparable alternative employment
erodeto gradually wear away or weaken somethingthe disappearance of local shops can erode the sense of community within a town
transactionalfocused on the exchange of goods or services rather than relationshipssupermarket transactions tend to be impersonal and transactional

Created by a Band 8.5–9.0 IELTS Writing achiever — Premium. Sign up free to see the ideas and vocabulary for this topic and unlock every model on the site.

Get free access →

Write your own answer

Draft your response below and get it marked against all four IELTS criteria — free, no account, one check a day.

0 words Check my answer

Answers checked here may be published on this page, without your name, to help other learners. Nothing else about you is stored.

Common questions

How do I write about change without sounding nostalgic?

Explain the mechanism instead of mourning the outcome. "Money leaves the area immediately rather than recirculating" is an argument; "things were better before" is a mood. Nostalgia is the most common way essays on this topic lose credibility.

Should I acknowledge that the cheaper option helps poor households?

Yes — it is the strongest point on that side and omitting it makes the essay look one-sided. Conceding that the gains matter most to those with least money makes your subsequent criticism far more persuasive.

Is it worth noting who gains and who loses?

It is one of the clearest markers of a high-band answer. Observing that advantages are broad and shallow while disadvantages are narrow and severe explains why opinion on the change divides so sharply, which no simple list of pros and cons can do.