Model answer
307 wordsIn numerous countries, a small elite accumulates wealth that far exceeds the average citizen's earnings. I agree that such individuals should be taxed at a significantly higher rate, although the specific rate must be set carefully to avoid undermining investment and economic productivity.
The strongest argument in favour of progressive taxation is its role in reducing wealth inequality and financing essential public services. When the wealthiest pay a greater proportion of their income, governments gain the resources needed to fund healthcare systems, state education, and social safety nets — services that disproportionately benefit lower-income groups. In Scandinavian countries such as Sweden and Denmark, high marginal tax rates on top earners have historically supported robust welfare systems and among the highest human development scores in the world. For those earning several times the national median salary, a higher tax rate represents a comparatively modest personal sacrifice while producing significant societal gains.
That said, the rate must be determined with precision rather than set arbitrarily high. If the burden becomes excessive, high earners — particularly entrepreneurs and investors — may relocate to lower-tax jurisdictions or reduce domestic investment, ultimately shrinking the very tax base governments seek to expand. France's brief experiment with a 75% 'supertax' in the early 2010s illustrates this risk: several high-profile individuals and companies transferred their activities abroad, and the policy was withdrawn after two years. A higher rate is therefore justified and beneficial, but only when calibrated to ensure that the incentive to generate wealth is preserved alongside the obligation to contribute to shared public goods.
In conclusion, I firmly agree that high earners should pay a higher rate of income tax, as the social benefits are substantial and the personal cost is proportionally manageable. However, policymakers must set the rate judiciously, ensuring it generates revenue without driving capital or talent out of the country.