Start practising

Opinion (Agree / Disagree) Society Task 2

Many elderly people are no longer looked after by their families but are put in care homes and nursing homes. What are the advantages and disadvantages of this trend?

A full IELTS Writing Task 2 answer to this question, with a paragraph plan and what this question type is asking you to do.

The question

You should spend about 40 minutes on this task.

Many elderly people are no longer looked after by their families but are put in care homes and nursing homes. What are the advantages and disadvantages of this trend?

Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.

Write at least 250 words.

How to read this question

You are given one statement and asked how far you agree. The examiner is checking that you take a clear position in the introduction and hold it consistently to the conclusion — a partial agreement is fine, an unclear one is not.

Paragraph plan

Introduction — Clear position stating both sides will be examined

Body 1 — Professional care and medical benefits

Body 2 — Emotional and family relationship costs

Conclusion — Balanced summary without opinion

Model answer

Model answer

269 words

The growing trend of placing elderly relatives in professional care facilities rather than providing family-based care represents a significant shift in how societies care for their aging populations. While this approach offers certain benefits in terms of specialized care and resources, it also raises concerns about emotional wellbeing and family relationships.

Care homes provide several distinct advantages, primarily centered on professional medical support and specialized facilities. Trained healthcare professionals can monitor chronic conditions, administer medications correctly, and respond immediately to medical emergencies, which many families lack the expertise to handle. Additionally, these facilities often feature specialized equipment such as mobility aids, emergency response systems, and modified living spaces designed for elderly residents' safety. The structured environment also ensures consistent daily routines, proper nutrition through professionally planned meals, and social interaction with peers facing similar life circumstances.

However, institutional care can create significant emotional and social disadvantages. Many elderly residents experience feelings of abandonment and isolation, despite the presence of professional staff who cannot provide the emotional intimacy that family members offer. The physical separation often leads to reduced frequency of family visits, gradually weakening intergenerational bonds and leaving elderly individuals feeling disconnected from their family's daily lives. Furthermore, the institutional environment, regardless of its quality, cannot replicate the familiarity and personal significance of the family home where decades of memories were created.

In summary, while care homes offer superior medical care, safety features, and professional support that many families cannot provide independently, they simultaneously risk creating emotional distance and weakening family relationships. The decision involves weighing practical healthcare needs against the psychological importance of family connections and familiar environments.

Model answers written and reviewed by The English All-in-One IELTS team. They are teaching models showing what each band looks like, not real candidate scripts.

This is an opinion (agree / disagree) question. The model answer above shows you what a strong answer looks like when it is finished. What it cannot show you is how to get there from a blank page in forty minutes.

That is what our Writing Study Library is for: the structure we teach for this exact question type, the paragraph pattern that goes with it, and the sentence openers for each stage — so the essay is planned before you start writing rather than assembled as you go.

See the structure for this question type →

Write your own answer

Draft your response below and get it marked against all four IELTS criteria — free, no account, one check a day.

0 words Check my answer

Answers checked here may be published on this page, without your name, to help other learners. Nothing else about you is stored.